For Meat Lovers: Ohana at Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort
Ohana is actually my favorite all-you-can-eat restaurant at Walt Disney World. First, I absolutely love Hawaii and everything Hawaiian-themed, so obviously I’m going to love any restaurant at the Polynesian Resort. But it’s the food that’s really got me. Even though it’s Hawaiian-themed, I would still consider it more of a Brazilian steakhouse for dinner. As they bring you to your table, they pick up some pineapple-coconut bread so you can start eating as soon as you sit down. Then they bring out a salad, dumplings and wings. While all of this food is delicious, pace yourself. The real star of the show is the meat. I suggest just a little taste of each of the appetizers (e.g., try to limit yourself to only one wing and one dumpling). I know it’s hard, but believe me, holding out is worth it. After trying to fill you up on the cheap stuff, the waiters will begin to bring around different meats on skewers and slide off as much or as little as you like. The options are chicken, shrimp and steak. The chicken and shrimp are great, but the steak is amazing. The steak alone would be enough to make this my favorite all-you-can-eat restaurant in Disney World.
For Seafood: Cape May Café at Disney’s Beach Club
Cape May Café is my mom’s favorite restaurant at Disney World. If you’re a seafood fan, this is the restaurant you want to go to. Fill up on buckets of clams, shrimp, mussels, crab legs and more. When I say buckets, I literally mean buckets. They have buckets there at the buffet for you to fill. And don’t worry if you’re traveling with land lovers. They also have a strip loin carving station and chicken available.
For Atmosphere: Biergarten at the Germany Pavilion in Epcot
Get the Oktoberfest experience without buying a flight to Munich. My husband (who is part German) absolutely loves the Germany Pavilion at Epcot because of the fun atmosphere and also because of the all-you-can-eat buffet full of German food. Enjoy a live German band while you load your plate with brats, schnitzel and other German specialties. Be sure to show off your moves during the “chicken dance” while you’re there.
For Little Ones: Crystal Palace in Magic Kingdom
I wouldn’t really consider the menu at the Crystal Palace as the best that Disney has to offer unless you’re a picky eater. In that case, it has plenty to offer for those who have a plain palate. Obviously, little kids typically fall under this umbrella, so it’s a good choice for parents with picky eaters. Plus, the Hundred Acre Wood Gang is all there. Your little ones will love meeting Winnie the Pooh, Piglet and Tigger while they enjoy all of their favorite foods—pizza, mac and cheese, chicken tenders, etc.
For Something Unique: Boma at Animal Kingdom Lodge
My brother’s favorite buffet at Disney World is Boma in Animal Kingdom Lodge, and it’s definitely at the top of my list as well. Unlike the Crystal Palace, I wouldn’t recommend it for picky eaters. However, if you’re more of the adventurous type, Boma is perfect for you. I think the food here is among the best at all of Disney World. My favorite dish is the bobotie. It’s kind of like an African version of shepherd’s pie, and it’s delicious. I also highly recommend any of the soups. The flavors of all the dishes at Boma are amazing, and I definitely suggest you add it to your dining plans while at Disney World.